Astrophysics

Switcheroo and Lanczos Gravity: MOND done right

Authors: Warren D. Smith

Einstein & followers proved GR(Λ) – general relativity with cosmical constant Λ – is the unique gravity theory obeying certain postulates. We show a loophole: allowing traceless Lanczos tensors abc permits more theories. That's desirable because GR contradicts observation – with two proposed remedies:

DM: copious invisible "dark matter"(≈5× "normal matter" mass, and distributed differently) exists;
MOND: replace GR by Milgrom's "modified Newtonian dynamics."

But: most experts claim DM has never been detected; MOND fits many observations better; and allowing any undetectable-DM distribution makes DM largely uncheckable/unusable. Meanwhile, MOND is theoretically unacceptable: not "generally covariant," with relativistic-MOND attempts ugly, complicated,highly non-unique, asininely demanding new fields ("dark matter" rematerializes!), and often afflicted with tachyons/acausality/instability.

We propose new simple "Switcheroo" (SG) and "Lanczos Gravity" (LG). Redone uniqueness arguments suggest LG/SG are the only theoretically-acceptable GR(Λ) extensions. LG uses Labc and/or its "superpotential" Pab to modify Einstein's field equation. SG obeys the unmodified equation, except Λ "switches" among multiple possible values, presumably from different quantum field (QF) vacuum phases in different places. Λ-stairstep phase-transitions ("switcheroos") occur when certain tensorial-invariant scalars F⃗ cross certain boundaries. The formulas for F⃗, while not entirely known, importantly involve LabcLabcand/or L*abcLabc (* means tensor dual). Remarkably, {Labc, Pab} exists only in 4 spacetime dimensions. Gravitationally Labc looks analogous to the "4-potential" vector Au in electromagnetism. In QF theories Au is central while electric/magnetic fields are not; so analogously Labc might underpin future "quantum gravity" theories, not Weyl's curvature tensor Wabcd.GR can be reformulated based on Ricci curvature Rab and {Labc or Pab}, rather than the metric gab. One should a priori expect switcheroos given no known reason for QF vacuum phase uniqueness yielding one Λ value always. For MOND-like SG behavior, F⃗ must involve Labc because invariants involving only the metric tensor and its derivatives cannot work.

LG/SG contain GR, hence fit observations no worse. LG/SG potentially could explain: galaxy rotation curves, early big bang "inflation," recently-alleged nonconstancy of Λ during cosmological (FLRW model) history, "Hubble tension," and solve:galaxy-formation puzzles, "lithium problem," "satellite problem," black hole paradoxes, and perhaps "defend" against singularities. I do not know whether SG/LG really accomplish that, or are garbage. Answering that question could be long and difficult for astronomers. Complications: LG/SG and DM could coexist; it's unclear how SG/LG should best-handle Lanczos nonuniqueness; and the full set of possible LG gravity theories remain unclassified.

Comments: 163 Pages. [CLAUDE was used]

Download: PDF

Submission history

[v1] 2026-11-01 21:47:47

Unique-IP document downloads: 22 times

ai.Vixra.org is a AI assisted e-print repository rather than a journal. Articles hosted may not yet have been verified by peer-review and should be treated as preliminary. In particular, anything that appears to include financial or legal advice or proposed medical treatments should be treated with due caution. ai.Vixra.org will not be responsible for any consequences of actions that result from any form of use of any documents on this website.

Add your own feedback and questions here:
You are equally welcome to be positive or negative about any paper but please be polite. If you are being critical you must mention at least one specific error, otherwise your comment will be deleted as unhelpful.